Fish It! Roblox Fish List — Cross-Checked Catches by Rarity and

Overview

The Fish It! community fish index organizes catches into Common, Uncommon, Rare, Epic, Legendary, Mythic, and Secret sections, but its page explicitly says it is a work in progress. For a usable fish list, treat the rarity tiers as a checklist and confirm each catch by location. The table below covers catches that the community index and at least one major location guide agree on.

How the Fish It! fish index is organized

According to the community index, Fish It! has over 415 fish and seven rarities ranging from Common to Secret. The index groups entries under those rarity headings and lists a location for each fish. Because the page is a work in progress and the official Roblox description announces new Arcadia fish, the complete present-day count cannot be established from these sources. Use the rarity sections to track what you have caught, and cross-check location guides before traveling.

Cross-checked Fish It! catches by location

Reference points:

• Clownfish — Common — Fisherman Island
• Azure Damsel — Common — Fisherman Island
• Reef Chromis — Common — Kohana
• Jennifer Dottyback — Common — Kohana
• Magma Goby — Uncommon — Kohana Volcano
• Manta Ray — Mythic — Open Ocean
• Monster Shark — Secret — Coral Reefs
• Abyss Seahorse — Mythic — Esoteric Depths
• Great Whale — Secret — Tropical Grove
• Axolotl — Legendary — Crater Island
• Robot Kraken — Secret — Lost Isle — Sisyphus Statue (not Treasure Room)

Starter and early-island catches

Fisherman Island is the starter island. The community index places Common Clownfish and Azure Damsel there; TechWiser's February 2026 list also places both at the starter island. The community index lists both at 1 in 2, while TechWiser lists Azure Damsel at 1 in 4. For Kohana, the community index and TechWiser both list Reef Chromis and Jennifer Dottyback among the island's Common catches, both at 1 in 2 in their tables. Magma Goby is an Uncommon Kohana Volcano catch in the community index and Pro Game Guides; the community index and TechWiser both list it at 1 in 55. Pro Game Guides describes Kohana Volcano as a great place for farming Magma Goby and recommends buying a boat for 50 Gold and getting the free Lava Rod from the Lava Fisherman NPC.

Mid-game and high-rarity locations

Several high-rarity fish are cross-checked by the community index and Pro Game Guides. Manta Ray is listed as a Mythic open-ocean catch; Pro Game Guides lists it at 1 in 50k. Monster Shark is a Secret Coral Reefs catch; Pro Game Guides lists it at 1 in 2.5M. Abyss Seahorse is a Mythic Esoteric Depths catch; Pro Game Guides lists it at 1 in 95k. Great Whale is a Secret Tropical Grove catch; Pro Game Guides lists it at 1 in 900k. Axolotl is a Legendary Crater Island catch; Pro Game Guides lists it at 1 in 6.5k. These odds are from the cited guides and were not independently tested.

Lost Isle: where Robot Kraken is caught

The community index and Pro Game Guides both place the Secret Robot Kraken at Lost Isle's Sisyphus Statue rather than its Treasure Room. Pro Game Guides lists Robot Kraken at 1 in 3.5M. Lost Isle has separate fishing areas, so check the location note before assuming a Secret belongs to the Treasure Room. For contrast, Pro Game Guides lists King Crab under Treasure Room, but Robot Kraken's entry is tied to Sisyphus Statue in both sources.

What the fish list does not confirm

The complete present-day fish count cannot be established from these sources. The community index calls itself a work in progress, and the official Roblox description announces new Arcadia fish. Listed catch odds were not independently tested and may change with game updates or buffs. Treat any single list as a snapshot, not a final collection checklist.